| Rank | School | Location | Tuition and Fees | Total enrollment | Fall 2013 acceptance rate | Average freshman retention rate | 6-year graduation rate |
| #105 | Augustana College | Rock Island, IL | $37,236 | 2,524 | 58.7% | 86% | 78% |
| #105 | Cornell College | Mount Vernon, IA | $37,500 | 1,125 | 58.9% | 82% | 68% |
| #105 | Goucher College | Baltimore, MD | $40,558 | 2,111 | 72.3% | 84% | 68% |
| #105 | Hampden-Sydney College | Hampden-Sydney, VA | $39,272 | 1,070 | 54.9% | 79% | 62% |
| #105 | Juniata College | Huntingdon, PA | $38,630 | 1,635 | 74.1% | 87% | 75% |
| #105 | Stonehill College | Easton, MA | $37,426 | 2,481 | 70.9% | 88% | 85% |
| #105 | Washington College | Chestertown, MD | $42,592 | 1,512 | 66.5% | 83% | 68% |
| #112 | Hollins University | Roanoke, VA | $34,295 | 750 | 69.3% | 70% | 60% |
| #113 | Hanover College | Hanover, IN | $33,023 | 1,163 | 66.7% | 81% | 72% |
| #113 | Ripon College | Ripon, WI | $33,482 | 904 | 75.2% | 85% | 74% |
| #113 | Siena College | Loudonville, NY | $32,293 | 3,216 | 57.5% | 87% | 80% |
| #116 | Calvin College | Grand Rapids, MI | $29,635 | 4,034 | 69.8% | 87% | 73% |
| #116 | Susquehanna University | Selinsgrove, PA | $40,350 | 2,187 | 72.3% | 84% | 75% |
| #116 | Sweet Briar College | Sweet Briar, VA | $34,935 | 710 | 84.3% | 74% | 57% |
| #116 | Westminster College | New Wilmington, PA | $33,410 | 1,359 | 73.4% | 86% | 77% |
| #120 | Coe College | Cedar Rapids, IA | $37,230 | 1,420 | 61.7% | 80% | 67% |
| #120 | Lake Forest College | Lake Forest, IL | $39,842 | 1,622 | 57.3% | 84% | 64% |
| #120 | St. Anselm College | Manchester, NH | $36,336 | 1,923 | 73.7% | 86% | 74% |
| #123 | St. Norbert College | De Pere, WI | $33,023 | 2,222 | 81.9% | 83% | 74% |
| #124 | Birmingham-Southern College | Birmingham, AL | $31,888 | 1,188 | 64.2% | 81% | 62% |
| #124 | Eckerd College | St. Petersburg, FL | $38,668 | 1,821 | 72.2% | 81% | 66% |
| #124 | Linfield College | McMinnville, OR | $37,346 | 1,671 | 92.2% | 83% | 68% |
| #124 | Presbyterian College | Clinton, SC | $33,650 | 1,433 | 66% | 82% | 68% |
| #124 | Randolph-Macon College | Ashland, VA | $36,340 | 1,315 | 63.7% | 78% | 61% |
| #129 | Berry College | Mount Berry, GA | $30,530 | 2,223 | 60.3% | 78% | 60% |
| #129 | Concordia College—Moorhead | Moorhead, MN | $34,114 | 2,558 | 78% | 84% | 71% |
| #129 | Goshen College | Goshen, IN | $29,700 | 888 | 55.1% | 79% | 70% |
| #129 | McDaniel College | Westminster, MD | $38,350 | 3,256 | 75.9% | 83% | 72% |
| #133 | Moravian College | Bethlehem, PA | $36,800 | 1,841 | 80% | 78% | 74% |
| #133 | Morehouse College | Atlanta, GA | $26,090 | 2,189 | 66.8% | 82% | 54% |
| #133 | Randolph College | Lynchburg, VA | $34,107 | 682 | 83.4% | 77% | 52% |
| #133 | Roanoke College | Salem, VA | $37,802 | 2,029 | 72.8% | 80% | 64% |
| #133 | Wesleyan College | Macon, GA | $19,900 | 697 | 43.4% | 79% | 64% |
| #133 | Whittier College | Whittier, CA | $41,711 | 2,373 | 63.3% | 83% | 66% |
| #139 | Alma College | Alma, MI | $34,220 | 1,419 | 69.4% | 80% | 61% |
| #139 | Central College | Pella, IA | $32,124 | 1,386 | 65.8% | 81% | 65% |
| #139 | Gordon College | Wenham, MA | $34,390 | 2,109 | 43.1% | 82% | 72% |
| #139 | Grove City College | Grove City, PA | $15,550 | 2,491 | 80.6% | 90% | 82% |
| #139 | Houghton College | Houghton, NY | $28,556 | 1,100 | 91.1% | 87% | 73% |
| #139 | Principia College | Elsah, IL | $26,850 | 480 | 84.1% | 80% | 82% |
| #139 | Simpson College | Indianola, IA | $32,550 | 1,773 | 88% | 80% | 65% |
| #139 | University of Minnesota—Morris | Morris, MN | $12,584 | 1,946 | 57.6% | 82% | 63% |
| #139 | Wittenberg University | Springfield, OH | $38,030 | 1,979 | 89.4% | 77% | 63% |
| #148 | Centenary College of Louisiana | Shreveport, LA | $32,000 | 661 | 66% | 71% | 59% |
| #148 | Hiram College | Hiram, OH | $30,290 | 1,311 | 57.3% | 76% | 66% |
| #148 | Nebraska Wesleyan University | Lincoln, NE | $28,500 | 2,149 | 76.9% | 79% | 68% |
| #148 | Oglethorpe University | Atlanta, GA | $32,500 | 1,082 | 55.8% | 78% | 62% |
| #148 | Salem College | Winston-Salem, NC | $25,356 | 1,187 | 58.3% | 77% | 64% |
| #148 | St. Vincent College | Latrobe, PA | $31,370 | 1,813 | 68.8% | 83% | 70% |
| #148 | Wells College | Aurora, NY | $36,700 | 534 | 59.7% | 73% | 58% |
| #155 | Carthage College | Kenosha, WI | $36,850 | 2,997 | 70.2% | 76% | 65% |
| #155 | Georgetown College | Georgetown, KY | $32,960 | 1,399 | 85.8% | 75% | 57% |
| #155 | Illinois College | Jacksonville, IL | $29,210 | 1,028 | 61.3% | 81% | 64% |
| #155 | William Jewell College | Liberty, MO | $31,620 | 1,043 | 57.8% | 75% | 59% |
| #159 | College of Idaho | Caldwell, ID | $24,625 | 1,122 | 68.3% | 85% | 67% |
| #159 | Lycoming College | Williamsport, PA | $34,706 | 1,307 | 71.6% | 81% | 64% |
| #159 | University of North Carolina—Asheville | Asheville, NC | in-state: $6,392, out-of-state: $21,263 | 3,784 | 68.7% | 80% | 60% |
| #159 | Wartburg College | Waverly, IA | $36,120 | 1,714 | 77.7% | 79% | 63% |
| #159 | Westminster College | Fulton, MO | $22,560 | 1,044 | 69% | 79% | 68% |
| #164 | Doane College | Crete, NE | $27,200 | 1,113 | 71.7% | 76% | 61% |
| #165 | Fisk University | Nashville, TN | $20,858 | 640 | 21.2% | N/A | 52% |
| #165 | Hartwick College | Oneonta, NY | $40,070 | 1,615 | 84.2% | 74% | 58% |
| #165 | Lyon College | Batesville, AR | $24,300 | 592 | 58.8% | 67% | 50% |
| #165 | Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts | North Adams, MA | in-state: $8,975, out-of-state: $17,920 | 1,716 | 67.2% | 75% | 57% |
| #165 | Monmouth College | Monmouth, IL | $33,200 | 1,256 | 64.3% | 75% | 59% |
| #165 | Warren Wilson College | Asheville, NC | $30,852 | 893 | 69.6% | 68% | 51% |
| #171 | Purchase College—SUNY | Purchase, NY | in-state: $7,873, out-of-state: $17,523 | 4,379 | 33.2% | 82% | 60% |
| #172 | Eastern Mennonite University | Harrisonburg, VA | $29,350 | 1,640 | 65.1% | 78% | 63% |
| #172 | Emory and Henry College | Emory, VA | $30,226 | 959 | 65.7% | 73% | 48% |
| #172 | Guilford College | Greensboro, NC | $33,430 | 2,302 | 68.2% | 74% | 57% |
| #172 | Northland College | Ashland, WI | $31,480 | 574 | 59.1% | 71% | 58% |
| #176 | Ouachita Baptist University | Arkadelphia, AR | $23,320 | 1,543 | 70.1% | 79% | 60% |
| #177 | Albright College | Reading, PA | $38,220 | 2,384 | 62.3% | 74% | 54% |
| #178 | Bridgewater College | Bridgewater, VA | $30,380 | 1,848 | 54.9% | 75% | 60% |
| #178 | Erskine College | Due West, SC | $31,280 | 815 | 69.7% | 68% | 58% |
| #178 | Wisconsin Lutheran College | Milwaukee, WI | $25,960 | 1,178 | 63.6% | 78% | 64% |
| #178 | Xavier University of Louisiana | New Orleans, LA | $21,552 | 3,121 | 54.4% | 68% | 46% |
| RNP | Allen University | Columbia, SC | $12,970 | 651 | 50.1% | 46% | 23% |
| RNP | American Jewish University | Bel-Air, CA | $29,132 | 229 | 41.8% | 70% | 53% |
| RNP | Amridge University | Montgomery, AL | $10,305 | 635 | N/A | N/A | 23% |
| RNP | Ave Maria University | Ave Maria, FL | $23,000 | N/A | 61% | 70% | 43% |
| RNP | Bay Path University | Longmeadow, MA | $30,859 | 2,359 | 57.6% | 74% | 55% |
| RNP | Bennett College | Greensboro, NC | $17,130 | N/A | 69.5% | 68% | 41% |
| RNP | Bethany College | Bethany, WV | $25,736 | 727 | 49.5% | 60% | 48% |
| RNP | Bethany Lutheran College | Mankato, MN | $24,450 | 579 | 74.6% | 72% | 49% |
| RNP | Bloomfield College | Bloomfield, NJ | $26,750 | 1,977 | 58.9% | 67% | 37% |
| RNP | Brevard College | Brevard, NC | $26,170 | 701 | 44.9% | 58% | 43% |
| RNP | Bryn Athyn College of the New Church | Bryn Athyn, PA | $18,610 | 276 | 52.3% | 64% | 50% |
| RNP | Burlington College | Burlington, VT | $23,546 | 244 | 82.8% | 62% | 17% |
| RNP | Castleton State College | Castleton, VT | in-state: $10,286, out-of-state: $24,014 | 2,175 | 78.9% | 71% | 51% |
| RNP | Claflin University | Orangeburg, SC | $15,210 | 1,884 | 60.6% | 73% | 44% |
| RNP | Clearwater Christian College | Clearwater, FL | $17,765 | 505 | 70.1% | 66% | 54% |
| RNP | College of Saints John Fisher & Thomas More | Fort Worth, TX | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | 33% |
| RNP | Colorado Mesa University | Grand Junction, CO | in-state: $7,625, out-of-state: $18,985 | 9,676 | 82% | 65% | 33% |
| RNP | Dillard University | New Orleans, LA | $16,191 | 1,183 | 35.4% | 64% | 48% |
| RNP | Eastern Nazarene College | Quincy, MA | $27,922 | 1,478 | 51.3% | 68% | 58% |
| RNP | Fort Lewis College | Durango, CO | in-state: $7,252, out-of-state: $17,780 | 4,065 | 87.5% | 64% | 37% |
| RNP | Green Mountain College | Poultney, VT | $32,436 | 841 | 75.6% | 70% | 40% |
| RNP | Harrisburg University of Science and Technology | Harrisburg, PA | $23,900 | 335 | 47.4% | 62% | 24% |
| RNP | Holy Cross College | Notre Dame, IN | $27,150 | N/A | 81.3% | 55% | 21% |
| RNP | Huston-Tillotson University | Austin, TX | $13,494 | N/A | 45.9% | 57% | 23% |
| RNP | Johnson C. Smith University | Charlotte, NC | $18,336 | 1,387 | 36.7% | 68% | 44% |
| RNP | Judson College | Marion, AL | $15,630 | N/A | 73.9% | 71% | 38% |
| RNP | Kentucky State University | Frankfort, KY | in-state: $7,404, out-of-state: $17,214 | 2,533 | 37.7% | 51% | 18% |
| RNP | The King's College | New York, NY | $32,300 | 516 | 71.2% | 64% | 61% |
| RNP | Lane College | Jackson, TN | $9,180 | N/A | 33.4% | 55% | 33% |
| RNP | Life University | Marietta, GA | $10,500 | 2,776 | 40.9% | 70% | 22% |
| RNP | Louisiana State University—Alexandria | Alexandria, LA | in-state: $5,315, out-of-state: $12,173 | 2,229 | 60.7% | 57% | 20% |
| RNP | Marymount Manhattan College | New York, NY | $27,636 | 1,833 | 74.7% | 66% | 44% |
| RNP | Maryville College | Maryville, TN | $31,754 | 1,168 | 72.6% | 72% | 56% |
| RNP | Pacific union College | Angwin, CA | $28,131 | 1,647 | 50.6% | 76% | 37% |
| RNP | Pine Manor College | Chestnut Hill, MA | $26,180 | 346 | 64.1% | 59% | 36% |
| RNP | Rust College | Holly Springs, MS | $9,286 | 922 | 13.9% | 60% | 20% |
| RNP | San Diego Christian College | El Cajon, CA | $25,888 | N/A | 42.6% | 59% | 44% |
| RNP | Savannah State University | Savannah, GA | in-state: $5,415, out-of-state: $15,176 | 4,772 | 82.9% | 70% | 29% |
| RNP | Shawnee State University | Portsmouth, OH | in-state: $7,364, out-of-state: $12,617 | 4,341 | 83.3% | 52% | 24% |
| RNP | Shorter University | Rome, GA | $19,670 | N/A | 68.1% | 54% | 49% |
| RNP | Simpson University | Redding, CA | $24,300 | 1,255 | 55.5% | 71% | 49% |
| RNP | Stillman College | Tuscaloosa, AL | $14,910 | N/A | 41% | 60% | 28% |
| RNP | SUNY College—Old Westbury | Old Westbury, NY | in-state: $8,436, out-of-state: $18,086 | 4,364 | 58% | 77% | 37% |
| RNP | Tougaloo College | Tougaloo, MS | $10,210 | 878 | 34.1% | 74% | 50% |
| RNP | University of Hawaii—Hilo | Hilo, HI | in-state: $7,036, out-of-state: $19,036 | 4,043 | 75% | 70% | 36% |
| RNP | University of Maine—Machias | Machias, ME | in-state: $7,490, out-of-state: $19,370 | 892 | 85.4% | 66% | 31% |
| RNP | University of Pikeville | Pikeville, KY | $18,290 | 2,204 | 100% | 52% | 29% |
| RNP | University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma | Chickasha, OK | in-state: $6,270, out-of-state: $15,210 | 917 | 62.5% | 67% | 37% |
| RNP | University of Virginia—Wise | Wise, VA | in-state: $8,868, out-of-state: $23,870 | 2,291 | 75% | 69% | 42% |
| RNP | University of Wisconsin—Parkside | Kenosha, WI | in-state: $7,316, out-of-state: $14,889 | 4,617 | 68.8% | 65% | 31% |
| RNP | Virginia Intermont College | Bristol, VA | $24,642 | N/A | 99% | 63% | 25% |
| RNP | Virginia Wesleyan College | Norfolk, VA | $33,286 | 1,459 | 92.9% | 65% | 44% |
| RNP | Western State Colorado University | Gunnison, CO | in-state: $7,874, out-of-state: $18,319 | 2,404 | 92.3% | 64% | 42% |
| RNP | West Virginia State University | Institute, WV | in-state: $6,228, out-of-state: $14,558 | 2,677 | 44.6% | 53% | 17% |
| RNP | William Peace University | Raleigh, NC | $23,900 | N/A | 61% | 68% | 38% |
| Unranked | Beacon College | Leesburg, FL | $31,496 | 190 | 64.8% | 69% | 81% |
| Unranked | Charter Oak State College | New Britain, CT | in-state: $8,592, out-of-state: $11,082 | 1,581 | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Unranked | East-West University | Chicago, IL | $18,795 | N/A | N/A | 32% | 12% |
| Unranked | Granite State College | Concord, NH | in-state: $8,775, out-of-state: $9,675 | 2,058 | 100% | 59% | 40% |
| Unranked | Hampshire College | Amherst, MA | $46,625 | 1,492 | 70.4% | 81% | 65% |
| Unranked | Marlboro College | Marlboro, VT | $38,110 | N/A | N/A | N/A | 61% |
| Unranked | Martin University | Indianapolis, IN | $11,960 | N/A | N/A | N/A | 13% |
| Unranked | National Hispanic University | San Jose, CA | $8,196 | N/A | N/A | N/A | 19% |
| Unranked | Shimer College | Chicago, IL | $31,527 | N/A | N/A | N/A | 34% |
| Unranked | Sterling College | Craftsbury Common, VT | $29,894 | N/A | 90.1% | 65% | 52% |
| Unranked | Talladega College | Talladega, AL | $11,492 | N/A | N/A | N/A | 21% |
| Unranked | Thomas More College of Liberal Arts | Merrimack, NH | $20,400 | 80 | N/A | 40% | 48% |
| Unranked | Ursinus College | Collegeville, PA | $46,075 | 1,596 | 66.3% | 90% | 79% |
