| Rank | School | Location | Tuition | Total enrollment | Fall 2011 acceptance rate | Average freshman retention rate | 6-year graduation rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 124 | Morehouse College | Atlanta, GA | N/A | 2,441 | 62.7% | 83% | 55% |
| 124 | Ripon College | Ripon, WI | $30,110 | 990 | 75.1% | 84% | 70% |
| 124 | Susquehanna University | Selinsgrove, PA | $37,280 | 2,261 | 73.2% | 85% | 77% |
| 124 | Westminster College | New Wilmington, PA | $32,700 | 1,608 | 60.8% | 86% | 74% |
| 130 | Alma College | Alma, MI | $30,960 | 1,417 | 72.9% | 78% | 67% |
| 130 | Gordon College | Wenham, MA | $32,100 | 1,898 | 39.7% | 85% | 74% |
| 130 | St. Anselm College | Manchester, NH | $33,810 | 1,899 | 71.4% | 85% | 73% |
| 133 | Concordia College--Moorhead | Moorhead, MN | $30,860 | 2,772 | 81.0% | 84% | 69% |
| 133 | Grove City College | Grove City, PA | $14,212 | 2,461 | 75.7% | 91% | 82% |
| 133 | Roanoke College | Salem, VA | $34,496 | 2,057 | 69.6% | 78% | 69% |
| 133 | St. John's College | Annapolis, MD | N/A | N/A | 78.1% | 90% | 68% |
| 133 | Wells College | Aurora, NY | $34,700 | 507 | 62.7% | 71% | 57% |
| 138 | Eckerd College | St. Petersburg, FL | $35,566 | 1,843 | 68.5% | 80% | 63% |
| 138 | St. Norbert College | De Pere, WI | $30,675 | 2,225 | 80.5% | 83% | 70% |
| 140 | Goshen College | Goshen, IN | N/A | 945 | 59.5% | 81% | 73% |
| 140 | Houghton College | Houghton, NY | $26,924 | 1,287 | 71.6% | 86% | 69% |
| 140 | McDaniel College | Westminster, MD | $35,800 | 3,374 | 75.3% | 81% | 73% |
| 140 | Moravian College | Bethlehem, PA | $34,484 | 2,003 | 79.7% | 80% | 76% |
| 140 | William Jewell College | Liberty, MO | $30,200 | 1,060 | 54.1% | 77% | 63% |
| 145 | Fisk University | Nashville, TN | $20,391 | 533 | 100.0% | 73% | 42% |
| 145 | Nebraska Wesleyan University | Lincoln, NE | $25,918 | 2,070 | 82.0% | 81% | 64% |
| 145 | Simpson College | Indianola, IA | $29,529 | 1,866 | 85.3% | 80% | 69% |
| 145 | St. Vincent College | Latrobe, PA | $29,311 | 1,929 | 67.0% | 83% | 73% |
| 145 | Wesleyan College | Macon, GA | $19,000 | 665 | 54.0% | 80% | 52% |
| 145 | Whittier College | Whittier, CA | $38,670 | 2,487 | 71.5% | 81% | 55% |
